New York City: Catacombs by Candlelight

Discover the secrets hidden beneath St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral in Little Italy with “New York City: Catacombs by Candlelight”. For $38 per person, this 1.5-hour guided tour offers a rare opportunity to step into off-limits areas of the historic church grounds, including two walled cemeteries that are usually closed to the public. The tour is well-regarded, with a 4.3 out of 5-star rating based on over 520 reviews, and is praised for the knowledgeable guides and engaging storytelling.

This experience is ideal for those interested in history, architecture, or religious sites. It combines educational insights with a special atmospheric setting—illuminated only by tea lights—creating a unique ambiance. While the tour is not fully wheelchair accessible due to one flight of stairs, it remains a compelling option for anyone eager to explore hidden NYC history. Be prepared with comfortable shoes and some cash, as well as respectfulness to the active parish.

Key Points

• Accessible from Little Italy in Manhattan with a meeting point at 266 Mulberry Street.
• Includes access to the only active Catholic catacombs in New York City.
• Walk through two cemeteries closed to the public, seeing graves of prominent Americans.
• Expert guides deliver entertaining and informative commentary, often with stories and historical context.
• Tour duration is 1.5 hours, with morning and afternoon options.
• Not fully wheelchair accessible due to stairs, and not suitable for visitors over 80 years.

You can check availability for your dates here:

Exploring the Historic Location of St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral

The tour begins at 266 Mulberry Street, near the corner of Jersey Street, in the heart of Little Italy. The Basilica of St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral is a vital piece of New York’s religious landscape, serving as an active parish. The tour emphasizes the distinctive architecture and historic significance of the church, which is one of only 93 basilicas in the United States.

You will learn about the land acquisition and construction of the church, as well as its defense against Protestant attacks, providing context for its military and religious history. The guide shares stories about the land’s early history and the role the cathedral played in protecting Catholic interests during challenging times.

Exclusive Access to Restricted Areas of the Church Grounds

One of the tour’s highlights is gaining entry into areas normally off-limits. This includes the vaults of the active catacombs, where Bishops and notable figures like Bishop John Connolly rest alongside prominent New Yorkers such as the Delmonico Family. The labyrinth of vaults features the remains of bankers, lawyers, merchants, and Civil War-era generals like Thomas Eckert.

The guides do a fine job explaining the purpose and history of these vaults, making the dark, candlelit atmosphere feel more poignant. Visitors appreciate the sense of stepping back in time and the tales of the notable individuals buried there.

Visiting the Two Walled Cemeteries of the Church

The tour includes walks through two cemeteries that are usually sealed off from public view. These cemeteries hold the remains of high-profile Americans and are not open to the general public, making this experience uniquely special. The cemeteries are quietly atmospheric, with historic gravestones and stories behind notable burials.

The cemeteries’ proximity to the church, along with the guides’ insights, makes for a compelling glimpse into 19th-century New York. Visitors find it fascinating to see the resting places of influential figures from the city’s past.

The Atmosphere: Candlelight and Reverence

The candlelit setting adds a layer of mystery and serenity to the tour. The tea lights provided create a gentle glow that enhances the historic ambiance inside the vaults and cemeteries. This lighting also encourages reverence and respect for the active parish, which continues to serve its community today.

The quiet, contemplative atmosphere is often highlighted by visitors as a notable feature. The dim lighting allows the architectural details of the vaults and the ornate gravestones to stand out, making the experience both educational and emotionally powerful.

More Great Tours Nearby

The Role of the Guides in Bringing History Alive

The guides on this tour are praised for their depth of knowledge and engaging storytelling. Many reviews mention guides like Ronnie, Jimmie, and Leo, who blend historical facts with anecdotes and humor. Their passion for the subject makes the experience more lively and memorable.

Guides clarify the significance of each burial site, share stories of the church’s history, and answer questions with enthusiasm. They often include funny tales, making the tour both informative and entertaining.

Practical Details: Duration, Check-In, and Accessibility

The tour lasts approximately 1.5 hours, with morning and afternoon sessions available. Check-in occurs at 266 Mulberry Street, and it’s important to arrive on time for the brief orientation. The tour is wheelchair accessible to some extent but involves a flight of stairs down to the catacombs, which limits access for full wheelchair users.

Comfortable shoes are recommended due to walking on uneven surfaces, and visitors should bring cash for any additional offerings. As this is an active parish, respectful attire—avoiding shorts or sleeveless shirts—is advised.

What’s Not Allowed and Safety Considerations

The tour prohibits video recording to preserve the quiet atmosphere and respect the active church environment. Visitors are asked to maintain reverence throughout, especially inside the catacombs and cemeteries.

While the tour is not fully wheelchair accessible, it is accessible for most visitors with some mobility considerations. The tour guides emphasize respect for the site’s sanctity, making it a meaningful experience suited for those interested in history and architecture.

Why This Tour Stands Out in NYC

What sets this catacomb tour apart is its rare access to active and historic burial sites in Manhattan. The guided storytelling and atmospheric candlelight create an experience that is both educational and profoundly moving. The small-group format ensures personalized attention and engaging interaction.

Compared to other tours, this experience emphasizes authenticity and respect for the site, making it ideal for history buffs, architecture enthusiasts, and anyone curious about New York’s layered past.

Final Thoughts on the Catacombs by Candlelight Tour

This tour provides a compelling look into New York’s Catholic history through exclusive access and expert narration. The $38 price, combined with the 1.5-hour duration, offers good value for an experience that’s both unique and informative.

While not suited for visitors over 80 or full wheelchair accessibility, most others will find the atmosphere, stories, and sights well worth the price. It’s a quiet, respectful journey into the hidden depths of Manhattan’s religious heritage, perfect for those who appreciate history, architecture, and a touch of mystery.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the tour accessible for wheelchair users?
The tour is not fully wheelchair accessible due to one flight of stairs down to the catacombs. It is partially accessible, so some visitors with mobility aids may face challenges.

What should I bring on the tour?
Bring comfortable shoes for walking on uneven surfaces, some cash for tips or extras, and wear weather-appropriate clothing. Remember that video recording is not permitted.

How long does the tour last?
The guided experience lasts approximately 1.5 hours. It runs in the morning and afternoon, with specific times depending on the day.

Are there any restrictions for participation?
The tour is not suitable for visitors over 80 years and not fully wheelchair accessible. Guests should be reverent and respectful, respecting the active church setting.

What makes this tour special?
The exclusive access to active catacombs and cemeteries combined with expert guides and the candlelit ambiance make this experience stand out among NYC tours focused on history and architecture.

Can I cancel or reschedule?
Yes, free cancellation is available up to 2 hours before the scheduled start, allowing flexibility for planning.

This “Catacombs by Candlelight” tour offers a captivating glimpse into New York’s hidden religious history, with guides passionate about storytelling and atmosphere. It’s a unique blend of education, reverence, and intrigue—well worth the $38 investment for those eager to explore lesser-known aspects of the city.

You can check availability for your dates here: More Great Tours Nearby