Bay Street Bastards Pub Crawl Shared Tour in Charleston

Dive into Charleston’s True Crime Tales with the Bay Street Bastards Pub Crawl

The Bay Street Bastards Pub Crawl in Charleston offers a unique twist on the city’s historic bar scene, blending storytelling of infamous crimes with visits to four iconic venues. For $35 per person, you gain an approximately 2-hour journey through Charleston’s shadowy past, led by a knowledgeable guide. This tour is perfect for adults aged 21+ who appreciate history, storytelling, and local legends, with an emphasis on true crime stories that you won’t easily find elsewhere.

The small group size of just six people ensures an intimate experience, enabling personalized stories and a relaxed pace. While alcoholic beverages are not included, you can enjoy cocktails at each stop on your own expense. The tour departs at 7:30 pm from the U.S. Custom House on East Bay Street, winding through historic sites and lively pubs. Reviewers highlight the excellent guides and engaging stories, though some note that the storytelling varies depending on the guide. This tour provides a fun, educational, and slightly eerie way to explore Charleston after dark.

Key Points

• Price: $35 per person, with most bookings made 24 days in advance
• Duration: About 2 hours of storytelling and pub visits
• Start Point: U.S. Custom House on East Bay Street at 7:30 pm
• Stops: Four historic venues including the Old Exchange & Provost Dungeon and Blind Tiger Pub
• Focus: Charleston’s true crime stories, pirates, highway robberies, and infamous local crimes
• Guide: Led by top-rated local guides, praised for their storytelling and knowledge

Starting Point at the U.S. Custom House on East Bay Street

The tour kicks off at the U.S. Custom House, where your guide introduces Charleston’s notorious criminal cases. These include tales of piracy, highway robberies, and even a brutal homicide of a local newspaper editor. The 30-minute stop is free of admission fees but sets the tone for the grisly and fascinating stories ahead. From here, the group moves through the historic district, immersing in Charleston’s criminal past.

Exploring the Dark Past at First Citizens Bank

The second stop is at First Citizens Bank, where the discussion centers on what motivates murderers. The guide explores whether criminal impulses or personal histories drive deadly deeds. This segment invites questions about innate evil versus circumstance, adding a psychological layer to the crime stories. The stop lasts about 30 minutes and remains free of admission charges, providing space for conversation and curiosity.

The Haunted Cells of Old Exchange & Provost Dungeon

Next, the Old Exchange & Provost Dungeon reveals Charleston’s pirate and smuggler underworld. Historically, the dungeon housed pirates, including members of Blackbeard’s crew, and colonial criminals. Prisoners endured damp, shadowy cells awaiting justice or execution. This 30-minute stop offers a haunting glimpse into Charleston’s gritty past, where crime and punishment intertwined beneath the city’s elegant surface.

The Speakeasy Secrets at Blind Tiger Pub

The tour’s final stop is at the Blind Tiger Pub, a former Prohibition speakeasy. Known for bootlegging, bribery, and secret backroom deals, the pub retains a rowdy, clandestine atmosphere. Inside, guests can sip cocktails (own expense) while hearing about Charleston’s outlaw past, where crime and cocktails flowed freely. This 30-minute visit adds a lively, authentic local flavor to the dark stories told during the tour.

Guide Personalities and Storytelling Styles

Reviewers praise the guides’ knowledge and personalities. Guides like Alex and Ken receive high marks for their entertaining, well-informed storytelling. Some guides tailor their stories to the audience, making each experience personal and engaging. However, storytelling quality can vary depending on the guide, with some reviews noting less enthusiasm or less detailed narratives on certain occasions. The guides are a highlight of the tour, making history accessible and fun.

The Pacing and Group Experience

With only six people, the tour maintains a relaxed pace that encourages questions and discussion. The 30-minute stops allow ample time to absorb stories and enjoy the atmosphere of each venue. The timing ensures the tour doesn’t feel rushed, and the group size fosters a more personal connection with the guide. Expect a combination of storytelling, walking, and pub visits, making it a dynamic experience suited for those who enjoy interactive history.

Drinking and Venue Atmosphere

While alcoholic drinks are not included, guests are encouraged to purchase cocktails at each venue. The stops include places with historic charm, like Blackbeard’s crew haunts and Prohibition-era speakeasies. Reviewers mention that the bars are interesting and atmospheric, enhancing the storytelling experience. Keep in mind that some stops may involve waits or limited seating, so flexibility can enhance your enjoyment.

Logistics and Meeting Details

The tour begins at 7:30 pm at the United States Custom House located at 200 E Bay St. It concludes at the Blind Tiger Pub on 36-38 Broad St. The tour is suitable for most travelers able to walk and stand for the duration, but heavy mobility issues are not specified. The mobile ticket ensures easy access, and free cancellation is available up to 24 hours before the start time.

What Sets This Tour Apart from Others

Unlike typical pub crawls, this experience emphasizes local true crime stories intertwined with Charleston’s historic bars and underground sites. The focus on infamous criminals and grisly tales makes it especially appealing for crime enthusiasts. The small group size guarantees a more personal and engaging experience, and the guides’ storytelling abilities stand out as a major strength.

The Limitations to Keep in Mind

While many reviews praise the quality of guides and venue atmosphere, some mention that storytelling can be inconsistent. One review notes that only three out of four advertised stops are visited, which may disappoint those expecting the full itinerary. Plus, the tour does not include drinks, so budget accordingly if you plan to enjoy cocktails at the stops.

Final Thoughts: Is the Bay Street Bastards Pub Crawl Right for You?

This tour offers an entertaining mix of Charleston’s true crime stories and historic bar visits. It’s most suited for adults ages 21+ who enjoy history, storytelling, and nightlife. The small group size and guided narration create a personalized experience that feels both informative and lively. Expect an evening filled with dark tales, local legends, and atmospheric venues.

While not a traditional pub crawl, this experience balances history and entertainment in a way that appeals to crime history buffs and history fans alike. The $35 price tag makes it a great value for those wanting a distinctive night out in Charleston’s historic district. Just remember, the stories and pacing depend on the guide, so flexibility is key.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this tour suitable for those under 21?
No, the tour is only for guests aged 21 and over due to alcohol consumption restrictions.

Are drinks included in the tour price?
No, cocktails are at your own expense at each stop, allowing you to choose your preferred beverages.

What if I want to cancel?
You can cancel free of charge up to 24 hours before the tour starts for a full refund. Cancellations made less than 24 hours in advance are non-refundable.

How many stops are visited during the tour?
Typically, four stops are included—U.S. Custom House, First Citizens Bank, Old Exchange & Provost Dungeon, and Blind Tiger Pub—though one review notes only three stops were visited.

What makes this tour different from other Charleston pub crawls?
The focus on true crime stories combined with historic venues sets this apart, appealing especially to crime history fans who want a story-driven experience.

Is this tour accessible for people with mobility issues?
While specific accessibility details aren’t provided, the tour involves walking and standing at multiple stops, so travelers should be comfortable with that level of activity.