The Blood on the Cobblestones True Crime Tour of St. Augustine offers a captivating look into the city’s most infamous unsolved murders and dark history. Priced at $35 per person, the tour lasts approximately 2 hours and features a small group walking experience, making it perfect for those interested in history, true crime, and local storytelling. The tour departs at 8:00 pm from Ghost City Tours of St. Augustine and ends at Prohibition Kitchen on St. George Street.

This tour is designed for adults aged 21 and over, focusing on dark chapters from the city’s past. It combines storytelling at six historic bars with visits to sites along the oldest streets in the United States. Reviewers highlight the knowledge and charisma of the guides, but note that the experience leans heavily on storytelling, which may be longer than some expect. Still, for true crime fans and history buffs, this tour offers an entertaining and educational evening.

Key Points

Price: $35 per person, with alcoholic beverages not included
Duration: Approx. 2 hours, starting at 8:00 pm
Stops: Six bars and historic sites in St. Augustine’s oldest streets
Highlights: Stories of unsolved murders, serial killers, and local scandals
Guides: Known for being knowledgeable and engaging, with some reviews praising their storytelling style
Age Restriction: 21+, with a mobile ticket for easy access
Weather: The tour requires good weather, with options for full refunds if canceled

Exploring St. Augustine’s Dark Past on a Night Walk

The Blood on the Cobblestones tour invites visitors to explore St. Augustine’s darker history through a small group walking tour. Starting at Ghost City Tours of St. Augustine, the experience takes you along the city’s oldest streets, where stories of murder, betrayal, and mystery unfold at each stop. The tour emphasizes local history, connecting stories to actual historic locations and bars that have been carefully selected to complement the narratives.

The evening begins with a visit to Charlotte Street, dating back to 1785, where the unsolved Delany murder still throws a shadow over the community. The guide shares intriguing details about this Florida’s oldest cold case, encouraging you to imagine the motives—revenge, greed, or something darker. The 20-minute stop is a compelling start to the tour, setting a tone of mystery and suspense.

Planning more time in St Augustine? We've covered other experiences worth considering.

From Charlotte Street to Florida’s Oldest Cold Case

Next, the tour visits Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila, where the story of W.D. Lindsey’s murder unfolds amidst southern scandal. The guide explains how betrayal and revenge played roles in this historical crime, leaving behind a stain on the city’s reputation. During this 20-minute stop, you can lean in for the chilling details of a crime that still sparks curiosity.

The third stop lands on Aviles Street, the oldest street in St. Augustine, where a murder in the 1800s shocked the city. The story of Juan Carlos, a trusted local figure, reveals themes of deceit and deadly consequences. The 20-minute session uncovers the whispers of betrayal that continue to haunt this historic district.

Unsolved Crimes from the 20th Century: Cadiz Street and Athalia Lindsley

In Cadiz Street, the focus shifts to the 1974 murder of Athalia Lindsley, a former model and political figure. Her brutal murder in daylight shocked residents, yet no one was ever convicted. This 20-minute stop explores the crime of revenge, passion, or silence, emphasizing that the full story remains unresolved decades later.

The fifth stop takes place at Saint George Street & Cathedral Place, where the brutal murder of Amy Blount in the 1990s shook the city’s sense of safety. During this 20-minute segment, the guide recounts the harrowing details and community reactions, illustrating how one violent act can change local perceptions.

The Pacing, Guides, and Overall Experience

The tour is paced to balance storytelling with pub stops, with each location offering about 20 minutes for stories and drinks. The guides, such as Rob, Jenna, and Alisa, are praised for their knowledge, charisma, and engaging storytelling. Several reviews note that guides bring history to life, making the experience both informative and fun.

While some mention the tour may be a bit long for those with limited attention spans, others appreciate how the storytelling enhances the local atmosphere. The bar stops are carefully selected, featuring craft cocktails and locally-owned venues, though alcoholic drinks are not included in the price.

Meeting Points, Group Size, and Booking Details

The tour departs from Ghost City Tours of St. Augustine, located at 32 Charlotte Street, and concludes at Prohibition Kitchen on St. George Street. With a maximum group size of 25, the experience remains intimate and engaging. Most travelers book 17 days in advance, highlighting its popularity.

Guests receive a mobile ticket, simplifying check-in at the starting point. The tour operates rain or shine, with the caveat that bad weather may lead to cancellations for which full refunds are available if canceled more than 24 hours in advance.

While you're exploring St Augustine, here are other experiences we've looked into

The Verdict: Is This Tour Worth It?

For $35, the Blood on the Cobblestones True Crime Tour offers a unique combination of historic sites and dark crime stories. The quality of storytelling and local bar visits differentiate it from typical walking tours. It’s particularly suited for adults interested in true crime, local history, or a different kind of night out.

While some reviews mention that the tour can feel lengthy, many find the stories captivating and the guides engaging. The focus on unsolved murders and local scandals provides a thrilling insight into St. Augustine’s more mysterious past.

Ready to Book?

Blood On The Cobblestones True Crime Tour of St Augustine

4.5

(101)

87% 5-star

“Rob was a fantastic and funny tour guide. He had some great insight and interesting facts about the murders of the so far past. Fans of true crime …”

— Brenden L, May 2025

Frequently Asked Questions

Is alcoholic beverage included in the tour?
No, alcoholic drinks are not included. Guests are encouraged to bring beer money for stopovers.

What is the age restriction?
The tour is only for guests aged 21 and over.

Can I cancel the tour?
Yes, cancellations are free up to 24 hours before the scheduled start, with a full refund available if canceled in time.

What should I bring on the tour?
Bring beer money or other drinks if desired, as drinks are purchased separately at the bar stops.

How long does the tour last?
The tour runs for approximately 2 hours.

Where does the tour start?
It begins at Ghost City Tours of St. Augustine, located at 32 Charlotte Street.

Is the tour suitable for all fitness levels?
Since it involves walking through historic streets, comfortable shoes are recommended, but the tour is generally manageable for most.

Are the stories suitable for all audiences?
The tour contains dark content related to murder and crime, so it’s best for adults only.

What makes this tour different from other historical tours?
This experience focuses specifically on true crime stories and local unsolved murders, with stops at bars for a more interactive, social experience.

How many stops are included?
There are six stops—each offering a story and time for drinks, creating a combination of storytelling and socializing.

This Blood on the Cobblestones True Crime Tour offers a fascinating glimpse into St. Augustine’s darker side, perfect for those who enjoy history, mystery, and a lively evening exploring the city’s most haunted tales.