NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour - Starting Point at Lt. Petrosino Square

NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour

Discover NYC's mobster past with this private 2-hour walking tour through Little Italy and Chinatown, led by expert guides with engaging stories and visuals.

Explore New York City’s Fascinating Gangster History for $275 per Group

NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour - Explore New York City’s Fascinating Gangster History for $275 per Group

The NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour offers an intriguing glimpse into the city’s notorious past, focusing on the powerful gangs that once ruled neighborhoods like Little Italy, Chinatown, and the Five Points area. Priced at $275 for up to 10 people, this 2-hour tour is perfect for groups seeking an engaging, personalized experience. The tour departs from Lt. Petrosino Square and ends on Mulberry Street, providing a walk through historic streets filled with stories of ruthless gangsters, mob bosses, and secret hideouts.

This private tour is led by a friendly, professional guide who brings history to life with vivid storytelling, visual aids, and insider details. With flexible departure times, it adapts easily to various schedules. While the tour emphasizes mob lore and neighborhood history, it’s especially suited for those interested in organized crime, American history, and urban legends. The only considerations are that it’s a walking tour with moderate physical activity and requires advance booking to secure a spot.

Key Points

NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour - Key Points

  • Private experience for up to 10 people at $275
  • Duration of 2 hours with flexible start times
  • Walks through Little Italy, Chinatown, and the Five Points neighborhood
  • Visit notable sites like St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral and a nearby FBI hideout
  • Learn about gang wars, mob families, and famous mobsters like John Gotti
  • Guided by knowledgeable, engaging tour leaders with visual aids

Starting Point at Lt. Petrosino Square

NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour - Starting Point at Lt. Petrosino Square

The tour begins at Lt. Petrosino Square on Lafayette Street, a meaningful location in NYC’s criminal history. From here, the guide takes you through streets once associated with Cosa Nostra and other gangs that left a mark on the city’s culture. The walking pace allows for question-asking and takes in the neighborhood ambiance, making it accessible for most visitors with moderate physical fitness.

Discover Little Italy’s Mobster Past

NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour - Discover Little Italy’s Mobster Past

The first stop is Little Italy, where stories of mob violence, rivalries, and the demise of mob leaders like John Gotti are shared. This neighborhood was once a hotbed of organized crime activity, with mob members gunned down in the streets. The guide explains how the mob operated in this area and highlights historical landmarks that bear witness to its past. This stop is free of admission fees, but it provides a vivid picture of the neighborhood’s notorious reputation.

Visit the Basilica of St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral

NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour - Visit the Basilica of St. Patricks Old Cathedral

Next, the tour takes you to the Basilica of St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral, a landmark featured in the Godfather film. Located just five minutes from the previous stop, this church has served as a spiritual hub amid NYC’s gritty history. It isn’t included in the admission fee, but the guide shares stories connecting the site to mob lore and the wider city’s criminal history.

See Hidden FBI Hideouts and Opium Dens

NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour - See Hidden FBI Hideouts and Opium Dens

A highlight of the tour is the visit to an FBI hideout, offering a rare glimpse into law enforcement’s efforts to combat organized crime. The guide shares insights into mob investigations and secret locations that played a role in the fight against criminal enterprises. The tour also mentions opium dens and clubs favored by mob bosses, illustrating the underworld activities that thrived in NYC’s past. These stops are not ticketed attractions, but the stories enrich the walking experience.

The Five Points Neighborhood and Its Mobster Roots

The Five Points area, once known as the most notorious neighborhood in NYC, serves as a central point in understanding the city’s gang history. The guide explains how this area was a hotspot for gang activity, with rivalries fueling violence and organized crime. Walking through the streets, visitors can imagine mob wars and immigrant rivalries that shaped the city’s criminal landscape.

The Guide’s Style and Visual Aids

NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour - The Guide’s Style and Visual Aids

The tour stands out because the guide uses a large binder filled with images, newspaper clippings, and visuals that help bring mob stories to life. This approach makes the history more engaging and easier to understand, especially for visual learners. Stories are told in a fun, relatable manner, often including sound effects that entertain all ages, according to positive reviews.

Logistics: Meeting Point, Group Size, and Accessibility

NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour - Logistics: Meeting Point, Group Size, and Accessibility

The meeting at Lt. Petrosino Square makes it convenient for those using public transportation, as the location is near major transit lines. The tour is private, meaning only your group participates, ensuring a personalized experience. The group size is limited to 10 people, favoring an intimate setting for questions and interaction. The tour does not include hotel pick-up or drop-off, so plan accordingly.

Value and Booking in Advance

At $275 for up to 10 participants, this tour offers good value for a personalized, expert-led experience. It is usually booked about 32 days in advance, highlighting its popularity among enthusiasts of crime history. For those interested, free cancellation is available if canceled at least 24 hours in advance, providing flexibility.

Highly Praised Guides and Visitor Satisfaction

From Tommy to Ray and Joel, the guides consistently receive top reviews for their knowledge, enthusiasm, and ability to entertain while delivering factual stories. Reviewers note that guides like Robin and Russ make the experience memorable with their engaging storytelling and visual aids, making it easy to connect with NYC’s mobster past.

Who Will Enjoy This Tour Most?

This private walking tour is ideal for history buffs, crime enthusiasts, and anyone curious about organized crime’s influence on NYC’s development. It’s especially suitable for groups who enjoy storytelling, street walking, and visual learning. Given the moderate walking and informative pace, it works well for most visitors with average physical fitness.

Final Thoughts on the NYC Gangster and Mob Tour

For $275, the NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour provides a rich, personalized look into the city’s gangster era. It combines history, storytelling, and visual aids to make complex stories engaging and accessible. The small group setting and expert guides enhance the experience, making it particularly appealing for those who prefer a more intimate exploration of New York’s darker past.

While it doesn’t include additional attractions or transportation, the tour’s strength lies in its detailed stories and neighborhood insights. It’s a great choice for anyone interested in mob history or looking for a unique NYC tour that goes beyond typical sightseeing.

✨ Book This Experience

NYC Gangster and Mob Private Walking Tour



5.0

(69 reviews)

88% 5-star

“Great tour lead by Tommy! Loved the history and stories that he shared about the mobs in NYC. Walking the streets of little Italy and learning abou…”

— Wendy L, Mar 2025

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this tour suitable for children?
The tour involves walking and storytelling about mob violence and crime, which may not be suitable for very young children. It is best for those with moderate physical fitness and an interest in history or crime stories.

Are there any additional costs during the tour?
The admission to St. Patrick’s Old Cathedral is not included, and there are no other mandatory fees. The guide’s visuals and stories are part of the tour experience.

Can I cancel or reschedule the tour?
Yes, free cancellation is available if canceled at least 24 hours before the scheduled start. Rescheduling options are not specified but canceling is straightforward.

What should I wear or bring?
Comfortable walking shoes are recommended, given the walking nature of the tour. Bring questions and curiosity—visual aids and stories are provided to enhance understanding.

Is this tour accessible for people with mobility issues?
The tour involves moderate walking, so travelers should have moderate physical fitness. No specific accessibility accommodations are mentioned, so it’s best to contact the provider if needed.

How far in advance should I book?
Booking about 1 month ahead is advisable, as the tour is often booked 32 days in advance. Early reservation guarantees your spot on this popular private experience.