St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl

Discover the True Crime Pub Crawl in Historic St. Augustine

The St. Augustine: True Crime Guided Pub Crawl offers a captivating look into the city’s darker past, blending local history with spooky stories of crimes and killers. For $35 per person, this 2-hour tour takes you through some of the most iconic pubs and historic streets, led by a knowledgeable guide who brings the chilling tales to life. The tour is designed for adults over 21 and is perfect for those interested in a mix of history, storytelling, and socializing.

What sets this tour apart is its focus on unsolved murders, serial killers, and notorious crimes that have left an imprint on St. Augustine’s long history. You’ll visit renowned venues like Forgotten Tonic and Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila, sipping drinks while hearing about grisly murders and intriguing cases. The tour’s intimate size—limited to 9 participants—ensures a relaxed atmosphere and personalized storytelling, making it ideal for small groups seeking a mix of entertainment and education.

While this experience is centered on stories rather than elaborate crime reenactments, it offers a unique way to explore the city’s historic art district and downtown streets. A key consideration is that food and drinks are not included, so you may want to plan for additional spending at the stops.

You can check availability for your dates here:

Key Points

• Price: $35 per person for a 2-hour guided pub crawl in St. Augustine
• Includes: Guided walk with stories of unsolved murders, serial killers, and historic crimes
• Stops: Pubs including Forgotten Tonic, Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila, and other downtown venues
• Focus: Dark stories from St. Augustine’s past, such as the case of William Darrell Lindsey and the murder of Father Rene Robert
• Group Size: Small groups limited to 9 participants, fostering an intimate experience
• Tour Timing: Usually held in the evening, rain or shine, lasting approximately 2 hours

Starting Point at Pizalley’s Chianti Room

The tour begins at Pizalley’s Chianti Room, located at 32 Charlotte St. This spot offers a selection of beverages to settle in before the storytelling begins. The guide leads the group through the night, sharing tales that include the murder of Father Rene Robert, known for helping ex-convicts, and exploring the history behind other grisly killings from 1800 on Aviles Street—the oldest street in the United States.

The meeting spot is convenient for those already exploring downtown St. Augustine, and it provides a relaxed environment where you can browse the drink menu while preparing for the evening’s stories.

Exploring the Crime Stories of St. Augustine

As the tour moves to Casa Reina Taqueria & Tequila, you’ll hear about the murder of Father Rene Robert. He was recognized for his efforts to assist ex-convicts, and his death remains a significant, though unsolved, crime in the city’s history.

Next, at Forgotten Tonic, the guide recounts a murder that occurred on March 2, 1800, on Aviles Street. This street, being in the heart of the historic district and the oldest in the country, adds an atmospheric backdrop to these stories.

The journey continues through Saint George Street and Cathedral Place, where participants can purchase drinks and learn about the unsolved murder of Lieutenant Guillermo Delaney. The guide also discusses the case of Athalia Ponsell Lindsley, a model, Broadway performer, and TV hostess, whose death remains a part of local lore.

The final stop at Prohibition Kitchen, a vintage-style gastropub, offers a perfect setting to conclude the tour. Here, the guide shares more stories before the group disperses, leaving with a heightened sense of St. Augustine’s haunted past.

Logistics and Group Experience

The meeting point at the Ghost City Tours store on 32 Charlotte St is easy to find. The tour runs for about 2 hours, typically in the evening, making it a great option for a nighttime activity. The walk covers approximately 0.9 miles, mostly through the downtown historic district and art art district, which adds visual interest to the storytelling.

The small group size of 9 participants ensures a more personal and engaging experience. The guide is known for being knowledgeable and enthusiastic, making the stories both entertaining and insightful. The tour is not suitable for minors under 21 and includes a strict policy against video recording.

Participants should bring passport or ID and driver’s license for verification, and be prepared for weather conditions since the tour takes place rain or shine.

More Great Tours Nearby

Value and Considerations

For $35, this tour offers a compelling mix of history, true crime stories, and social atmosphere in some of St. Augustine’s most iconic pubs. The stories are well-researched, covering a range of cases from local serial killers to unsolved murders, adding a layer of intrigue to your city exploration.

However, it’s important to note that food and drinks are not included. While you can purchase beverages at each stop, the focus remains on the stories rather than the drinking itself. Some feedback indicates that the tour’s crime stories are not overly graphic but are interesting enough for those with a curiosity for true crime.

Final Thoughts: Who Will Appreciate This Tour?

This True Crime Pub Crawl in St. Augustine appeals most to adults over 21 interested in history, crime stories, and local legends. It’s ideal for travelers looking for a relaxed yet engaging activity that combines drinks, storytelling, and exploration of the historic district.

The small group size and knowledgeable guide make for a personalized experience, while the focus on local murder cases offers a different perspective on St. Augustine’s past. Those with a fascination for unsolved crimes or serial killers will find this tour particularly compelling.

While it may not satisfy those seeking a visual or reenactment experience, it delivers authentic stories in a cozy, social setting. Be prepared for a casual pace and to purchase your own drinks during stops.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this tour suitable for children?
No, it is only for participants over 21 due to alcohol consumption and adult themes.

What should I bring on the tour?
Bring passport or ID and driver’s license for identification purposes.

Are drinks included in the tour price?
No, drinks are not included; you can purchase beverages at the stops.

How long does the tour last?
The tour runs for approximately 2 hours.

Where does the tour start?
It begins at Pizalley’s Chianti Room at 32 Charlotte St.

What are the main stories covered?
Highlights include William Darrell Lindsey, Father Rene Robert, Lieutenant Guillermo Delaney, and Athalia Ponsell Lindsley.

Is the tour walkable?
Yes, the 0.9-mile walk takes you through downtown and historic streets.

Can the tour be canceled?
Yes, cancellations are accepted up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund.

What if it rains?
The tour takes place rain or shine, so dress appropriately.

You can check availability for your dates here: More Great Tours Nearby